Challenges for both sides


Font size: [A] [A] [A]

Newly re-elected Scranton Councilwoman Janet Evans was correct Tuesday night when she declared that newly re-elected Mayor Chris Doherty is "going to have to learn to work with others."

Because Mrs. Evans and her "team" of Patrick Rogan and Frank Joyce won, they'll name a replacement for departing Councilman Bill Courtright, who was elected as tax collector. Thus, they will have a veto-proof majority on council.

The question is whether such a majority, in juxtaposition to the city's strong-mayor form of government, will produce consensus or gridlock. So dealing with the new political reality on the council is indeed Mr. Doherty's challenge.

The council majority's challenge, however, is to bring more than opposition to the table. It is to do more than say "no" - to present viable alternatives when it rejects the administration's initiatives. It is not simply to thwart Mr. Doherty, but to move the city forward.

The brand of opposition led by Mrs. Evans during her time in the minority was the easiest kind because the administration was left to effect policy. The power inherent in the majority creates the responsibility to come up with something better.







7 posted comments

"The council majority's challenge, however, is to bring more than opposition to the table. It is to do more than say "no" - to present viable alternatives when it rejects the administration's initiatives. It is not simply to thwart Mr. Doherty, but to move the city forward."

Prepare for the gridlock, voters, unless Rogan and Joyce have more sense than Mayor Evans, and hopefully they do. Sucks that Janet retains her seat, but let's see what Team Rogan does. It's not her team anymore.

Reader 11/05/09 04:49
I am AMAZED. The problem won't be with Counsel. It will be - and always has been - with the one who has been described as someone who
"doesn't play well with others".

Please Scranton Times, stop with your spin in order to protect yourself. Which is a major cause of your dwindling readership.

This mayor is a polarizing agent.

He, and only he, is the reason for the discourse.

Remember, this is the paper that endorsed Doug Miller and Lee Morgan. They would have endorsed Judy Gatelli too if she didn't wait to announce her write-in in order to escape the wrath of the counsel speakers.

Something's rotten in Denmark....and it isn't the new counsel.

Non-yellow journalist 11/05/09 01:23
I am so happy I live in Wilkes-Barre instead of Scranton!
soul sister 11/05/09 11:56
Could we please appoint Ray Lyman? To me, he was the best. Always direct and to the point, well researched before he spoke and just a gentleman.
Ray Lyman 11/05/09 11:47
Yeah, your right Brenda K., businesses detest political bickering and will not locate in those municipalities. There's no more political bickering than on Dickson City council and that's why so many businesses have chosen to locate somewhere else. Businesses will locate where they draw the most customers and pay the least amount of taxes. Doherty has done nothing to lower those restrictive taxes and the reason businesses will not locate in Scranton. On top of that are the people in this city who refuse to allow anything that may be considered progress in the business sense. Most businesses want mini malls and require a lot of space, something Scranton is running short on. In those remaining areas where business and industry have attempted to locate in, they have met with opposition from residents or other business already here for fear of competition. What you choose to call bickering others may see as spirited debate. It's no secret that Evans does not see eye to eye with Doherty and visa versa. The question equally remains can Doherty put aside his personal deceit towards Evans and cooperate with a new majority on council. Obviously, the residents of Scranton weren't as happy with the direction Doherty has taken us in as he claims they were. The council vote and the amount of votes from a write in mayoral candidate indicate so. If he truly has interest in this city he will work with this new council. I don't think he can. So let's not just mention Evans' name in this question because Doherty, although not as out spoken about it, displayed as much criticism towards Evans in his actions.
Rolo Tomassi 11/05/09 09:41
The key or challenge for Mrs. Evans and team should be an easy one. Just take all the bugetary largess of Chris Doherty and cut it all out. Then use that money to remove the business taxes. That should achieve an equal playing field with other communities and the businesses will no longer have an excuse not to relocate back to Scranton. The taxes, (business privledge and mercantile) are not a large percentage of the total tax revenue received by the city. They can be easily eliminated. The real challenge and scurge of the city is the wage tax. That is the biggest revenue generator of all the taxes. A significant lowering of that tax will be hard to do, but at least getting it down a bit will surely help. I don't believe paying a few hundred dollars more than you would pay compared to outlying communities would keep the migration out of the city going, but the way it is now, is absolutely why it is happening. Maybe the creation of a 1% sales tax in the city (which other municipalities implemented) and thus using that increased revenue to offset the wage tax is a possibility. Other than that, a combination of Doherty patronage jobs cuts, bidding out ALL contracts and services, and cutting the wasteful spending of the past 8 years, must be achieved to cut the wage tax. Then and only then can we get some positive tax relief that will, in turn, actually increase revenue by getting working families and businesses to move into the city and increase our tax base.
On another positive note, if the new tax colletor Mr Courtright increases the efficiency of the tax office's collection of taxes and collection of delinquent taxes, all the extra money collected, and the cuts in the city's expenses, should be earmarked for the decrease in our wage and business taxes. It can be done if the new city council and tax collector get serious about it. Getting a handle on this tax and spend mayor, in combination with increased revenue is the only way to do it.
And maybe this paper will give it a chance and support those incentives instead of, what I predict will happen. They will side with the mayor and fight the new council, calling them obstructionists. We will then continue down the road to ruination, continued political hijinks and bankruptcy. I bet on the latter, since this is the Scranton we all know too well.
Margaret 11/05/09 07:55
Ms. Evans and her fellow council members will be challenged by the economic climate. Her skill at criticism will be no help in attracting businesses and jobs. Business owners and managers detest political bickering. They want leadership and pro active people in local government. We'll soon see if Janet is that leader or merely an inept official who drives business and jobs to other more hospitable communities.
Brenda K 11/05/09 06:24

Manhunt ends in West Scranton

A chaotic manhunt through West Scranton that started with state police firing shots at a suspect ended Friday night with the apprehension of a wanted man who two days earlier allegedly led authorities on a high-speed chase through the Midvalley. Derek


 

Manhunt ends in West Scranton

A chaotic manhunt through West Scranton that started with state police firing shots at a suspect ended Friday night with the apprehension of a wanted man who two days earlier allegedly led authorities on a high-speed chase through the Midvalley. Derek


 


POLL

Do you watch "The Oprah Winfrey Show"?

Show results

Evergreen570

Evergreen570 was created to share ideas and concerns about making and keeping our planet green. Think globally - act locally.

Obituaries

Read Local Obituaries

Search

Ask The Professional

Ask The Professional is an advertising feature that can help you find answers to those hard to ask questions regarding your health. The Q&A column appears online and in the Health & Science section of The Times-Tribune.