Last Masses bring tears


Font size: [A] [A] [A]

The Most Rev. James C. Timlin consolidated the feelings of hundreds Sunday as he served as principal celebrant at the closing Mass for St. John the Evangelist Church in South Scranton.

"I loved St. John's," the bishop emeritus said, tearing up during his homily. "We thank God for all the glorious memories we have of this parish."

Closing rites were also held Sunday at Sacred Heart of Jesus Church in Mayfield as the diocese consolidates 209 parishes into 118.

An air of sorrow enveloped both ceremonies, and participants cried during the final Masses.

"It's a sad day," Christine Tocki-Mulvey of Mayfield said as she sat on the vestibule steps at Sacred Heart with her 5- and 3-year-old sons.

"I was married in this church. My kids were baptized here," she said.

Bishop Timlin was a member of St. John the Evangelist Church until age 10, when his family moved to North Scranton. He received his first Communion in the church and attended the parish school. He amused the congregation Sunday with his recollections.

"This is undoubtedly a sad occasion for all of us," he told about 300 parishioners who attended the final Mass. "It has to be - difficult as it is. ... The faith goes on and life goes on."

St. John the Evangelist is being consolidated into Sacred Hearts of Jesus and Mary Church, about four blocks away. The parish will be called St. Paul of the Cross.

Bill Walsh, 78, a lifelong member of St. John the Evangelist Church, was among the ushers taking up the final collection. He was baptized in the church.

"I don't want it to happen, but what are you going to do?" Mr. Walsh said as the Mass concluded. "It was a good parish. I have some very good friends here."

About 250 people packed Sacred Heart of Jesus Church in Mayfield, which is consolidating with Sacred Heart of Mary Church in Jermyn to form Sacred Hearts of Jesus and Mary Parish.

"When a church closes, it's very similar to a death," the Rev. Thomas Shoback, pastor of Sacred Heart in Jermyn, said during his homily at the closing of the Mayfield church. "We go through that grieving process, but we know in the end, that hurt begins to heal. ... We begin to form a new community of faith."

Contact the writer: jhaggerty@timesshamrock.com







28 posted comments

Last thought on the female priest thing, unless the Bishop or Cardinal care to pipe in (wish they would). I cannot find the 11th commandment - "Thou shalt not ordain a female.", or even the 12th "Thou shalt not ordain a married man." In fact, I have had a widower priest (with children), and note that the Church sometimes welcomes in former Anglican (married) priests.
I don't believe I was created any more in God's image than my lovely wife - and she certainly feels the same way. There's an added complication. Maybe 51% of us are born female, 48.9% of us born male, but a small percentage of us are born with both sets of organs! Can they be priests? Nuns? Both? Neither? Why? Who gets to decide? Why did God do that? Finally, I have a fantasy - the Holy Spirit (maybe God the Mother???? Ever seen a picture????) get's really angry at the people who've been eliminating half the flock from the job. Again, take my advice - make the people happy. Include the statues from all of the closed ethnic churches in a grotto (people will volunteer time and materials to do this). Have all the ethnic foods at the picnic. Sing all the ethnic hymns. Occasionally have an ethnic priest over to celebrate a Polish, Italian, Irish, Russian, whatever Mass. Celebrate the diversity God created - including the fact that you are outnumbered, and ought to recruit from the MAJORITY for the priesthood. Remember, God the Mother could be watching! (The opinions expressed herein are my own, and not necessarily the opinion of my Church and/or my old religion teachers..... Sigh.)
Bishop O'Hara Grad 10/01/09 06:17
Cindy
Once you are inside the "club" of priests you hear how they put women down all the time... laugh at women who want to be priests.. call them "feminazies" and lezbos and other terms. I know because I personally heard it and it has not changed. This patriarchal church is corrupt and drunk with power hungry men who want to PRESERVE, PROTECT AND DEFEND THEIR SOLE RIGHT TO PRIESTHOOD. Nowhere in the scriptures are women barred from priesthood. Nowhere in scriptures does it say you must have male genitals to be a priest. All male priesthood defames women and prevents the Gospel mandate to go and preach the word to all nations. Christ did not say only males could do it. He surrounded himself with women of Galilee all the time. Rememember the first to see and experience the Resurrection of Christ was Mary Magdala NOT a man. Watch all the male priests jump in and get defensive.. like they need to defend their machoness and their elite "club".
Raymond 09/29/09 09:08
Cindy, Your whole assesment of the church closings is based on....."FROM WHAT I'VE HEARD, Bishop Martino did nothing to try and bring the Catholic church back to where it could have been"....Hearsay is never reliable and being on the outside looking in, does NOT avail you to it's inner workings. In addition, it is totally arrogant, which I think is not your intent, to ASSUME that the Catholic church is NOT WILLING to examine TRUE BIBLICAL FAITH and seek revival. In fact, Bishop Martino courageously maintained and upheld the authentic taching of the magisterium , a reason why he was persecuted so mercilessly. As for suggesting the church IMPLEMENT Bible study and other fellowship groups. These things are not foreign and abound here in great numbers. There are Bible study groups, holy hours, centacles, prayer groups galore. One notable group focuses on the "unreachable", the "marginalized". It reaches out to drug addicts, prostitutes, alcoholics and just your average homegrown sinner, like you and me. Bet You didn't know the Bishop brought this one to our diocese and participated in a major way. He was a part of this in Philadelphia and he brought it to fruition here, being an integral part of it for the last 6 years. If I knew you I would invite you to accompany me for a night of fellowhip at any one of these. So there is no monopoly on this knowledge and these concerns. But,it is also the responsability of people to seek a closer walk with the lord and rearrange their priorities and create revival in their soul. A difficult thing in this very selfish,materialistic and me centered society that is first and foremost looking to "Feel good" rather than to seek good. You say Bishop Martino in your opinion made "thoughtless" and "selfish" decisions? On what do you base that? Can you consider that these decisions were "necessary" and made with "great sadness"? Be careful to leave room for benefeit of the doubt when evaluating circumstances when you only have only half truths.
No half truths, please 09/29/09 07:11
To Strength in Numbers...

17 years ago, when I suggested to the Bishop that my niece would make a good priest, he said, "we're Catholics - we don't believe that". I asked, why not. He said "God said so". I said "where did he say that? He asked, "where did you go to school?". When I answered Bishop O'Hara, he ended the conversation, grabbed my shoulder, pushed me out of the way, and never was able to give me a citation in the Bible. Until the Catholic Church quits ignoring half the flock, and allows the other half with the predispostion to go into the priesthood to reproduce itself, they are going to have a priest shortage. Can you show me the citation in the Bible that says I'm wrong????

Bishop O'Hara Grad 09/29/09 05:37
From what I have heard, Bishop Martino did nothing to try and bring the Catholic church back to where it could have been. Evangelical churches share their faith with others, have Bible study groups and fellowship groups to bring new folks into the church, but it seemed as if nothing was done to bring a change where people would want to join the Catholic church, into being. There would have to be a revival of true Bibical faith in order to see any changes, and the Catholic church is not willing to examine this. I think it is sad to see any church close down as the people there took great pride in their faith and grew up in that church. The lies told about the Bishop's being expelled is wrong, and everyone knows he did wrong, and crossed a lot of people as well as made some very thoughtless and selfish decisions.
Cindy 09/29/09 01:18
From what I have heard, Bishop Martino did nothing to try and bring the Catholic church back to where it could have been. Evangelical churches share their faith with others, have Bible study groups and fellowship groups to bring new folks into the church, but it seemed as if nothing was done to bring a change where people would want to join the Catholic church, into being. There would have to be a revival of true Bibical faith in order to see any changes, and the Catholic church is not willing to examine this. I think it is sad to see any church close down as the people there took great pride in their faith and grew up in that church. The lies told about the Bishop's being expelled is wrong, and everyone knows he did wrong, and crossed a lot of people as well as made some very thoughtless and selfish decisions.
Cindy 09/29/09 01:18
From what I have heard, Bishop Martino did nothing to try and bring the Catholic church back to where it could have been. Evangelical churches share their faith with others, have Bible study groups and fellowship groups to bring new folks into the church, but it seemed as if nothing was done to bring a change where people would want to join the Catholic church, into being. There would have to be a revival of true Bibical faith in order to see any changes, and the Catholic church is not willing to examine this. I think it is sad to see any church close down as the people there took great pride in their faith and grew up in that church. The lies told about the Bishop's being expelled is wrong, and everyone knows he did wrong, and crossed a lot of people as well as made some very thoughtless and selfish decisions.
Cindy 09/29/09 01:18
Gene, When will you be putting out your shingle as a Phd. or other some bona fide mental health professional. As you feel inspired to give a diagnosis alluding to Bishop Martino's mental state. You would be wise to Stop repeating this destructive jargon concerning him as it only proves trhe point that there are those who continue ro tell a falsehood hoping that if you say it long enough there are those who will buy it, pick up on it and thus continue it without any basis except repeating the falsehood they've heard. Which are you, the perpetrator or the gullible.

'if you say a lie enough

Question to Gene. 09/29/09 11:56
Bishop O'hara Grad, You say "17 years ago when I suggested my neice would make a good priest, If you had listened there would be no priest shortage today".... well, also if we had put in multi screen high tech media with rock concert style services and slick sermons that gave you a grading on the amount of contributions you made, we might just be filled to capacity.... That's right, levels of contributing... booming evangelical local church TV broadcast tells of pyramid giving.. lowest level: tithing is the obligation. 2nd level is more, and according to what you think you can comfortably afford... BUT, The third level, the biggy is stepping out of your comfort level because "THAT'S WHEN YOUR BLESSINGS COME IN"...... try that sermon in a lot of Catholic churches and see how many would even hold out on that dollar they eeked out in the collection basket on Sunday..... And as for your suggestion "stick ro your guns with the abortion thing. It's written in stone The people will respect you for that" Well, that's what Bishop Martino did!!! He was recognized nationally as a great crusader for life. And He never waivered. RESPECTED?? ... He and priests who have the courage to stand up for life are mocked and ridiculed and persecuted. I have seen this time and time again!!! I have heard the comments and seen the disrespect..So, with women priests, rock music,highlights that focus on sermons to beat the band, not the sacred gift of the Eucharist, we might have bigger numbers but this would not make a better church only a watered down, unrecognizable version of one.
strength isn't in numbers.. 09/29/09 11:43
Wildunner...yes...Brian did a great job on the altar back when Father Kearney was in charge there. Brian's works can be seen throughout the city. For example, the bookshelves down at Gallo and Gowley law firm are his craftsmanshit. Very sad that this Church is closing.
Steve C. (Cedar Ave) 09/29/09 11:32
Gene - How dare you say that Bishop Martino had mental health issues. He stood strong on the teachings of the church and had to make some very hard decisions re: churches and schools. The church and school closings are happening across the country because people have put their self interest above their need for God, their want it their way not the church's way. Bishop Martino spoke the truth, at all times. He and many other Bishops saw that the Faithful Citizenship Document was not a true representation of the teachings of the church. I know for a fact that the Bishops were given the document last one night and asked to vote on it the next morning. Sounds a lot like what happens in Washington.
You Should Be Ashamed 09/29/09 10:38
It is really a sad time. The church is our mother. No wonder so many are going astray, just like when your mother goes the family goes with it also
family man 09/29/09 08:34
Advice for the Cardinal:

Leave the Cathedral. Talk to the people. Show them the charts - there's too little money and too few priests. Then compromise. Move the statues from the closed churches into the open churches - have a Polish grotto, an Italian grotto, and an Irish grotto. Sing a Polish song at the 9:00 AM Mass; an Italian song at the 11:00 AM Mass - and an Irish song at the 1:00 PM. Have a tri-chair for the Church Bazaar - and make sure their are pierogies, sausage, and ham and cabbage. Stick to your guns on the abortion thing - it's written in stone. The people will respect you for that one.

One last thing, if Bishop Timlin had listened to an old Bishop O'Hara graduate 17 years ago when I suggested that my niece would make a good priest, you wouldn't have the priest shortage now, would you?

Bishop O'Hara Grad 09/29/09 05:27
The Catholic church has been in disaray for some time now. People have been turned off and have gone elsewhere to seek spiritual guidance. I have nothing against the church even though I did not agree with its politics(which never belonged in the church) I have felt comfortable practicing my christianity in the Episcopal church. I feel for those who found comfort in their churches and will pray that they find and connect to another parish for their spiritual guidance. It is a shame that the church made so many blunders in particular naming Martino as the Bishop of Scranton.It was already dwindling but he pushed so many people away from the church. I believe he had mental health issues and poor communication skills. I blame those for putting someone like that in charge.
Gene 09/29/09 02:02
boo hoo, another house of lies closes
jackson ruffin 09/29/09 12:49
Advice for the Cardinal:

Leave the Cathedral. Talk to the people. Show them the charts - there's too little money and too few priests. Then compromise. Move the statues from the closed churches into the open churches - have a Polish grotto, an Italian grotto, and an Irish grotto. Sing a Polish song at the 9:00 AM Mass; an Italian song at the 11:00 AM Mass - and an Irish song at the 1:00 PM. Have a tri-chair for the Church Bazaar - and make sure their are pierogies, sausage, and ham and cabbage. Stick to your guns on the abortion thing - it's written in stone. The people will respect you for that one.

One last thing, if Bishop Timlin had listened to an old Bishop O'Hara graduate 17 years ago when I suggested that my niece would make a good priest, you wouldn't have the priest shortage now, would you?

Bishop O'Hara Grad 09/28/09 10:08
Should we all demand that Martino leave Dalton and go back to his diocese of incardination.. namely Philadelphia? That is where he belongs. Heard the folks back there don't want him back there. St. Joe's University is not happy with what he stirred up on campus and how he rubbed the Cardinal's nose in it all. Send old Joe back to where he belongs. Why should we foot all his bills.
Robin 09/28/09 07:35
Bernie - I don't know what Church you go to. Many churches I've attended in the Scranton Diocese have wonderful Priests who give dynamic Homilies. I actually attended one today at noon in the upper valley. I don't buy your excuse of why people aren't attending church. The real reason is that everything else in their lives is more important to them. They'd rather go out late on Saturday and then be too tired to get up for church on Sunday. I also have a news flash for everyone - this is happening across the country, not just in Scranton. And for using the preaching resources from the U of S and Kings and Marywood and Misericoria, don't see much of anything that looks Catholic to me coming out of these "so'called" Catholic Colleges.
FYI 09/28/09 02:08
St. John's is a great church. I loved the blue carpeting and the altar installed by Brian Houston. He did such a nice job with that church. It will truly be missed.
Wildunner 09/28/09 01:47
I love how they send out Bishop Timlin to close the church. He's always good for shedding a few tears about the past with the hope that people will feel better after seeing him cry. Where is Martino and Rigali? Our church is currently being lead by cowards. Once our church had martyrs who would die for the faith. Now, the leaders of our church won't even sacrifice a Sunday afternoon to be with parishiners as they close their church for the last time. We know Martino has taken a forty year vacation completely paid for by the people of this diocese. Where is Rigali? Oh, I forgot, he is retiring in six months at age 75 and doesn't care what happens here either.
If you have the gall to close a church, at least show up and finish the job. 09/28/09 01:38
Half Off Nepa

1/2 OFF NEPA

Today's Feature: Steve Pronko Diamond and Fine Jewelry - Card Value: $50 Sale Price: $25. - Earning Your Trust Since 1928!

Home for the Holidays Contest

Answer the trivia questions for your chance to win 4 tickets to the NEPA Philharmonic's "Home for the Holidays" concert.

Woman accused of using stolen debit card in Scranton

SCRANTON - A 30-year-old woman was charged with forgery Thursday for using a stolen debit card at two Keyser Avenue businesses in the summer, city police said. Latasha Wilson, no address listed, admitted using the card a


 

Scranton, police/fire unions both claim victory in judge's ruling

Both sides are claiming victories after a judge's ruling on arbitration awards granted to Scranton's police and fire unions in the past year. For the unions, the decision by visiting Monroe County Judge Peter O'Brien brings their members another step clo


 

Dimock families sue natural gas driller

Fifteen families in Susquehanna County filed a federal lawsuit against Cabot Oil and Gas Corp. on Thursday, saying the Texas-based natural gas operator damaged their property and health while drilling for gas in the Marcellus Shale. The families, who l