Diocese of Scranton eliminates 55 teaching positions


Font size: [A] [A] [A]

After 36 years of teaching high school students social studies, first at Bishop Hoban and then at Holy Redeemer, Jim Maloney received the notice in the mail.

The Diocese of Scranton doesn't need him anymore.

"The most disappointing part was our administration did not have the courage to call us and tell us to our faces that we are being dismissed," he said.

Mr. Maloney's job is one of 55 teaching positions eliminated across the Holy Redeemer and Holy Cross regional school systems, which include schools in Luzerne, Lackawanna, Wayne and Bradford counties. In addition, salaries will be frozen for all employees, but school employees' health insurance premiums will not increase.

Letters informing teachers of their status were mailed Monday, but the official announcement was not made until Thursday in The Catholic Light, the diocesan newspaper.

Elementaries hit hard

Most of the eliminations, 36, come from the closing of SS. Peter and Paul Elementary School in Plains Twp., St. Aloysius Elementary School in Wilkes-Barre and St. Vincent Elementary School in Honesdale. The other 19 eliminated positions are due to continued declining enrollment across the two systems.

Projections for the 2009-10 school year show Holy Redeemer system enrollment down 357 students, from 3,496 to 3,139. The Holy Cross system enrollment is projected to decrease by 296 students, from 3,198 to 2,902.

"The Diocese hopes to see its school systems grow and continue to operate into the future. At the same time, we must continue to monitor the viability of all of our schools. Hopefully, parents will recognize the value of a Catholic education and enrollment will stabilize," spokesman Bill Genello said via e-mail.

Callbacks possible

If enrollment increases by the beginning of the school year, it is possible the laid-off teachers could be hired to handle the additional students, according to the diocese.

Teachers will be eligible to fill open positions at other schools with the diocese, based on seniority and other criteria outlined by the diocese. They will continue to receive salaries until Aug. 21 and health benefits until the end of August.

Michael Milz, president of the Scranton Diocese Association of Catholic Teachers, which is fighting for recognition from Bishop Joseph Martino, said he is upset that because the union is not recognized, the teachers have no protection and are at-will employees who can be let go at any time.

"The fair system, and the way any other system works, is last hired is first to be asked to leave in a layoff," Mr. Milz said. "This will destroy the system. It destroys morale. It rewards no one for dedication.

"They used them up and threw them away when they didn't need them anymore."

Contact the writer: emoody@citizensvoice.com

More coverage of faith and religion

Find and discuss complete coverage of religion in Northeast Pennsylvania at thetimes-tribune.com/faith








105 posted comments

Mr.Betchel, how can you possibly ask the question of why aren't more parents enrolling their kids in catholic school? You do realize that in luzerne county there were four high schools, they were all closed by martino and opened as one. There used to be over 1500 students between all of them, now less then 800 remain, that happened in less then two years. I will give you one guess who caused this problem of lower enrollment. And it wasn't the teachers, parents, or students. Apparently before the almighty OZ decided to do this, plenty of families sent the kids, now that they have seen what burdens are now placed on them due to the closings and what other hardships they face and the way they were treated as well as the teachers, they have come to the realization that it's not worth it. To bad the diocese didn't come to that conclusion before they did all this. If only martino would of listened to the parents groups who tried in vain to meet with him and discuss the plans to save the schools, and only if he had met with the teachers and allowed an honest vote, but alas that did not happen and now we all know the fruit that is bearing because of that.
Jason Warde 06/12/09 12:38
Why not get replacement teachers from India to keep the schools open?
Jack M 06/12/09 12:36
The free ride of the Catholic Church is over. The bond and trust that many Catholics had for generations has been severed by the Church itself. The world has changed and with technology so has most people's attitudes. People are not loyal to anything anymore and once the church betrayed it's members with the abuse scandal the last thread of undying loyalty was lost and began to unravel. People make their own decisions now and think and formulate what is right or wrong for their own life circumstances. The population is no longer ignorant or illiterate, but the church has failed to recognize this. Add to all of this a poor, ineffective and pompous leader like Martino and all credibility is gone. The catholic church always counted on the power they had through the loyalty of their flock. The last political election proved that the majority of Catholics don't listen anymore and we are now seeing an institution hemmorage before our very eyes. Whether it survives in it's present form is uncertain. The Catholic Church closes churches, seminaries and schools. They close everything but the regal palaces, rectories and mansions where the hierarchy live. Anything the Catholic Church does now is based on money and for the survival of the institution and not for the God it was supposed to serve.
Pius 06/12/09 12:28
People don't send their children to Catholic schools because they don't get the quality of education that they once produced. Gone are the days of nuns, and priest who taught very well, now it's mostly kids fresh out of college waiting to get into a school district. Catholic schools are nothing but subsidised private schools for the finacially well off draning our parishes dry, close them all and be done with it.
That being said, the Bishop, in my opinion, is a coward for not laying off these people in person.
Had Enough 06/12/09 12:28
People don't send their children to Catholic schools because they don't get the quality of education that they once produced. Gone are the days of nuns, and priest who taught very well, now it's mostly kids fresh out of college waiting to get into a school district. Catholic schools are nothing but subsidised private schools for the finacially well off draning our parishes dry, close them all and be done with it.
That being said, the Bishop, in my opinion, is a coward for not laying off these people in person.
Had Enough 06/12/09 12:17
Father Dave Bechtel,
Yes the cost of tutition does drive parents to take their chidren out of the schools. But look at the private schools in the area, their tution is higher, yet they seen to attract students. As a marketing suggestion the Diocese can state the test scores of their students, the small class size, technology in the classroom. I agree the Diocese needs to know the reason for the decrease in the student population. May be a survey should be placed on their web site.
Tony 06/12/09 12:12
I want to draw attention to the fact that their are call backs possible. The paper made that fact clear.

There is a very simple solution to this problem based on that fact: If parents enroll their children in Catholic School, they will not have to close, and teachers will not have to be laid off.

The question is "Why aren't more parents enrolling their children?"

Father Dave Bechtel 06/12/09 12:07
Concerning social justice:
Re-instate the union.
Radio Girl 06/12/09 12:05
Drew,

Enough already. I don't support the fact that teachers have to be laid off and nor does the bishop. Do you really think for one minute the bishop enjoys having to do this? Do you really think for one miniute I think it is a great thing that our schools are shrinking and teachers have to be laid off? I hate it. I have a lot of respect and admiration for our teachers. I wish we could give them more. I don't like it at all. Funding for the schools is NOT unlimited. Reflect on the fact that I did not create the laws of economics, nor did the bishop. The bishop has no power over those laws, nor do I.

Who has power over those laws? The country as a whole. Since power lies with the people, then the people need to change the laws they have created. The value of money comes not from money, but from the people. Since people place such a high value on money, money has value. If people did not place such a high importance on money, money would be worthless. In short, the power of money is a phantom, for the power behind the throne is the people themselves.

Father Dave Bechtel 06/12/09 12:00
We can all argue about the best way the Diocese should have handled this situation, but however they choose to handle it, the situation does not change: teachers were laid off.

It seems to me people think that the Catholic Church is oblivious to economic realities. That the laws of business and economics do not apply when it comes to making decisions in the Church. They DO, unfortunately. I don't like that reality any more then the next person does, but the Church is NOT oblivious to economic realities, and never has been. When the economy goes south, the Church suffers like everyone else does. Like everyone else, the Church must consolodate, and must cut expenses, yet try to increase revenue.

When it comes to matters of the Gospel, those are free to anyone who seeks. But when it comes to running schools and institutions, the bottom line is a harsh reality and is a determining factor as to what the Church can realistically DO. I don't understand why people would think it would or should be different in the Church. If someone wants to dialog on that issue, I am willing to listen.

I invite people to reflect on the fact that it is not God, nor the Church that has created the laws of business and economics, but man. Money is imaginary. The paper is real, but the value behind the paper is imaginary. The people are the ones who put value on it. It is the people who say "If you want to have thus and so, then you must give us X amount of paper dollars to have it. If you don't have X amount of paper dollars, then you may not have it unless or until you DO."

This is not the Church's rule, the Church did not come up with this law, but it is SUBJECT to that law. This means like everyone else the Church must make decisions based on the bottom line. Again, that is not our law, we did not create that law, God did not create that law. Men did. This is one of the consequences of the laws men have created. If people do not like this, then the people need to change it, since they are the ones who created it in the first place.

Father Dave Bechtel 06/12/09 11:51
Martino's days should be filled talking to Catholic College Presidents, negotiating with teacher's unions, burying the priests of the Diocese who have given a lifetime of service and ministering to the poor and personally visiting every church, school and building that he intends to close. Instead, he spends his days worried about college commencement speakers in other states, Senator's personal lives, St. Patrick Day Parade floats and whether the Jesuits are hiding condoms on the University of Scranton campus. The Catholic Church as become a one trick pony obsessed with stem cells and abortion and could now care less about the needs of the living, breathing, struggling people in the pews every week. If Martino did his job properly he would not have to run home to his mommy every time someone questioned him or gave him a dirty look or put a microphone in his face, he would stand there and take it like a man and face the repercussions of his decisions.
Aquinas 06/12/09 11:50
If you want your kids to get a great education, send them to a private school (Wyo Sem, MMI, etc.) where the teachers are high caliber and well-paid. Catholic Church is a cult. They have you believe that flesh-and-blood men (priests) have "special powers" and that only THEY can absolve you from sin, baptise you, marry you, and even bury you. All for MONEY MONEY MONEY. It is a cult!
Saw the Light 06/12/09 11:19
it is a shame that this is happening. By the time this Bishop is thru there will be no Catholic churches or schools left.
M. Tansley 06/12/09 11:17
Why didn't Martino at least call the five people who support him daily by posting on this site including the Catholic Priest to make the calls for him to these 55 teachers? At least they could hear the news of their demise from the diehard, proud Catholics who bow daily before the Bishop's throne and support his every word and deed. Let them explain to these teachers why they are being discharged after 30 years of faithful service. Msgr. Siconolfi also announced his retirement today. I give the Bishop six months before he rules that St. Francis Kitchen is no longer economically feasible. A Republican Bishop like Martino caught feeding the poor and hungry in the example of Jesus would be thrown out of the Republican Party and would no longer receive his weekly talking points from Rush Limbaugh to use in his letters and sermons.
Drew 06/12/09 11:17
If you want your kids to get a great education, send them to a private school (Wyo Sem, MMI, etc.) where the teachers are high caliber and well-paid. Catholic Church is a cult. They have you believe that flesh-and-blood men (priests) have "special powers" and that only THEY can absolve you from sin, baptise you, marry you, and even bury you. All for MONEY MONEY MONEY. It is a cult!
Saw the Light 06/12/09 11:04
What schools laid off?

I hate Martino

Chris 06/12/09 10:50
If this article is correct, Martino and his minions are cowards. Somebody who works for 36 years for the Diocese deserves better than a form leter. Why no face to face meetings? Doesn't seem like the Christian way of handling things.
Nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition 06/12/09 10:32
last hired, first fired? Oh come on, seniority doesn't make you a good teacher, it just inflates your self worth. I've had some pretty bad teachers who were lifetime employees and some pretty good teachers who were in their first year. If anyone is going to be laid off it should be based on their worth to the organization. If you can't teach worth a darn, but you've been there for 20 years then you should be the first to go since it's your fault that the institution is failing. Blame any spelling and grammatical errors on the fine education I received from those very same experienced teachers.
um, no 06/12/09 10:20
It may be called the Catholic Church but it certainly is NOT CHRISTIAN in its actions. Another reason to support non-denominational places of worship....hmmmm that group is building churches due to increase in membership.
ben 06/12/09 10:17
Unfortunately, these teachers are paying the price for Martino's obsession. He really wants to fire the heretical professors at Kings, Misery, Marywood & the U. You know,the ones who teach tolerance & inclusion. Since he can't, he's taken it out on the Diocesan teachers.
Catholic school grad 06/12/09 10:08
Half Off Nepa

1/2 OFF NEPA

Today's Feature: Steve Pronko Diamond and Fine Jewelry - Card Value: $50 Sale Price: $25. - Earning Your Trust Since 1928!

Home for the Holidays Contest

Answer the trivia questions for your chance to win 4 tickets to the NEPA Philharmonic's "Home for the Holidays" concert.

Manhunt ends in West Scranton

A chaotic manhunt through West Scranton that started with state police firing shots at a suspect ended Friday night with the apprehension of a wanted man who two days earlier allegedly led authorities on a high-speed chase through the Midvalley. Derek


 

Manhunt ends in West Scranton

A chaotic manhunt through West Scranton that started with state police firing shots at a suspect ended Friday night with the apprehension of a wanted man who two days earlier allegedly led authorities on a high-speed chase through the Midvalley. Derek


 

Manhunt ends in West Scranton

A chaotic manhunt through West Scranton that started with state police firing shots at a suspect ended Friday night with the apprehension of a wanted man who two days earlier allegedly led authorities on a high-speed chase through the Midvalley. Derek