Diocese of Scranton eliminates 55 teaching positions


Font size: [A] [A] [A]

After 36 years of teaching high school students social studies, first at Bishop Hoban and then at Holy Redeemer, Jim Maloney received the notice in the mail.

The Diocese of Scranton doesn't need him anymore.

"The most disappointing part was our administration did not have the courage to call us and tell us to our faces that we are being dismissed," he said.

Mr. Maloney's job is one of 55 teaching positions eliminated across the Holy Redeemer and Holy Cross regional school systems, which include schools in Luzerne, Lackawanna, Wayne and Bradford counties. In addition, salaries will be frozen for all employees, but school employees' health insurance premiums will not increase.

Letters informing teachers of their status were mailed Monday, but the official announcement was not made until Thursday in The Catholic Light, the diocesan newspaper.

Elementaries hit hard

Most of the eliminations, 36, come from the closing of SS. Peter and Paul Elementary School in Plains Twp., St. Aloysius Elementary School in Wilkes-Barre and St. Vincent Elementary School in Honesdale. The other 19 eliminated positions are due to continued declining enrollment across the two systems.

Projections for the 2009-10 school year show Holy Redeemer system enrollment down 357 students, from 3,496 to 3,139. The Holy Cross system enrollment is projected to decrease by 296 students, from 3,198 to 2,902.

"The Diocese hopes to see its school systems grow and continue to operate into the future. At the same time, we must continue to monitor the viability of all of our schools. Hopefully, parents will recognize the value of a Catholic education and enrollment will stabilize," spokesman Bill Genello said via e-mail.

Callbacks possible

If enrollment increases by the beginning of the school year, it is possible the laid-off teachers could be hired to handle the additional students, according to the diocese.

Teachers will be eligible to fill open positions at other schools with the diocese, based on seniority and other criteria outlined by the diocese. They will continue to receive salaries until Aug. 21 and health benefits until the end of August.

Michael Milz, president of the Scranton Diocese Association of Catholic Teachers, which is fighting for recognition from Bishop Joseph Martino, said he is upset that because the union is not recognized, the teachers have no protection and are at-will employees who can be let go at any time.

"The fair system, and the way any other system works, is last hired is first to be asked to leave in a layoff," Mr. Milz said. "This will destroy the system. It destroys morale. It rewards no one for dedication.

"They used them up and threw them away when they didn't need them anymore."

Contact the writer: emoody@citizensvoice.com

More coverage of faith and religion

Find and discuss complete coverage of religion in Northeast Pennsylvania at thetimes-tribune.com/faith








105 posted comments

http://www.bishop-accountability.org/
Saw the Light 06/12/09 11:36
Father Bechtel,
You write, "The bishop hopes some day to re-open Pius." Have any cost analyses been computed as to how much such an endeavor might cost?
Gman 06/12/09 10:50
This is a follow up to my earlier post, 06/12/09 at 7:51AM.
bishop martino did not deign to humble himself and celebrate the funeral mass for Father Valentine Plevyak, 92 years of age and a priest in the Scranton Diocese for nearly 65 years. The auxillary bishop was the main celebrant.
Now compare that with the attendees at the funeral service for slain PA State trooper Josh Miller. Among the mourners were PA Governor, Ed Rendell AND U.S. Senator Bob Casey.
A side by side comparison of these two events speaks volumes as to the dysfunctional nature of martino as a person. If these two busy leaders can take time out from their busy schedules what is God's name can be martino's reason for not celebrating Fr. Plevyak's mass?
martino should either get intensive sensitivity training or find a new profession, say as Mafia vescovo to local mob figures.
Gman 06/12/09 10:46
It's a tragic shame the Bishop doesn't have enough respect for human life to notify his teachers to their faces. What a hypocrite.
Berni Royce 06/12/09 09:58
Hello Father Bechtel. The blog goes well, and thanks for asking.

Regarding Bishop Martino, I do not know the man personally, but merely read of his actions (mainly in the Catholic Light, for the record). Since you have more experience with Joseph Martino the man, I’ll defer to your opinion on his desire to keep the schools open. However and as we’ve discussed many times, sometimes with the Bishop his true desires are masked by an execution style that seems more authoritarian than truly pastoral.

As for the laws of economics, well many businesses are hurting these days, and there is no doubt in my mind that this has had an impact of the school situation. What’s fair to debate though is just how much it has impacted the current situation. Regarding solutions, I obviously don’t have all the answers (unlike many on the Internet…), but I do have a suggestion: if as a Catholic Community we want schools, then it’s time for all of us…parents, parishioners, students, teachers, administrators and Bishop…to act in concert and collective act to save these important institutions. I passionately believe that part of acting in concert would require a step that I think even you Father Bechtel would acknowledge that the Bishop would never take, namely allowing lay teachers in the Diocese to decide for themselves whether or not they wish to be represented by an independent union. The moment Bishop Martino unilaterally decided that lay teachers could not have an independent union is the moment that he decided that the only opinion that counted was his, and his alone. That kind of execution style does not lend itself to a community of support.

Thanks for reading/listening and while I don’t agree with everything you write, I do admire the fact that you publicly have taken a stand on these complex issues. In fact, I think the Bishop himself could take learn a thing or two about honest communication from what you’ve written.

Stephen Albert 06/12/09 09:37
To whomever seems to be so full of him or herself to think they are the only person out there with the initials "JC" I have been posting here as "J C" for quite some time (and fully intend to continue doing so) and have never seen any of your posts before today.

What is Bishop Martino destroying?

The congregation.

That's what.

Longstanding Catholic traditions in the region.

That's what.

With the weak position that the church is already in with scandals and lack of trust, this brings his motivations of continuing to cause problems and rifts, rather than ANY attempts at healing the community, all the more into question.

What would Jesus do? Whom did Jesus reach out to? Did he only focus on preaching to the choir and ignore the rest? Or did he instead reach out to the doubters and the skeptics? Martino only seems to want to preach to the choir and has no use for anyone else. He's drinking his own bathwater. Like I've said before, Martino has SERIOUSLY lost his way.

J C 06/12/09 09:18
Everything out there shows people leaving the Diocese in droves, to either join other churches or to turn their backs on the church altogether.

That is fact.

And Bishop Martino seems to not care that people are leaving, and cares not about drawing people in. Seems to be the attitude of "well, they weren't real Catholics anyways, who needs 'em".

And here goes yet another opportunity lost, in providing not only an education to children, but an education which includes traditional Catholic values.

Bishop Martino just doesn't get it.

Who needs HIM?

J C 06/12/09 09:07
It has amazed me for many years, the talks from the pulpit on how much the church always needs and never has enough money. How uneducated or naive do they think the parishioners are in this day and age? I don't know how they can state these lies while surrounded by marble and gold! If they are so broke, where are the millions coming from to pay off the abuse lawsuits? And how many were paid off quietly over the years that the public will never know about?
C 06/12/09 09:01
Walter,

Actually Rumors are that your going to be his next secretary.

I guess that's why you shouldn't pay attention to rumors.

Father Dave Bechtel 06/12/09 08:29
You are right father,
People, by thier choices do make the rules of economics. And, right again you are, the church is not exempt from thoes rules. Since the flock no longer values the leadership of the Diocese, all that the Church offers is no longer in demand. First the seminary closed, now the schools, and soon there will be but a few chruches left. No need to spend time or money on vocations, there are fewer faithful who need ministers. So, all is well and maybe darwin was right afterall. The strong survive. All that is not essential fades away. Maybe evolution is just God's way of pruning the world.
truly sorry 06/12/09 08:08
"Folks, folks...do we REALLY want the Church adopting kids? I mean, talk about asking foxes to watch the henhouse..."

I know that youre not resorting to stereotypes or anything John Smith so what gives with the above statement? Especially since...
A. there is the fact that less than 1.5% of priests had ever been accused of abuse.
B. the term "pedophile priests" widely used in the media, implies a distinctly higher rate of child molesters within the Catholic priesthood when in reality the incidence is lower than most other segments of society".

Sources cited http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Catholicism#cite_note-63. Souce cited in article;Philip Jenkins, Pedophiles and Priests: Anatomy of a Contemporary Crisis (Oxford University Press, 2001
also http://www.davidmacd.com/catholic/priest_sexual_abuse_cases.htm

The Real JC 06/12/09 08:08
Fr. Dave,
Rumors have you as the new Secretary to the Bishop?
Walter 06/12/09 06:51
The Real JC,

Great post! Thank you!

Father Dave Bechtel 06/12/09 06:03
Folks, folks...do we REALLY want the Church adopting kids? I mean, talk about asking foxes to watch the henhouse...
John Smith 06/12/09 05:57
R,

One other point:

None of this is necessitated becasue of the abuse crisis. Even if the abuse crisis NEVER HAPPENED, we would still be in this situation.

I am also a graduate of the UOFS, and a graduate of Saint Pius X. The bishop hopes some day to re-open Pius. Pius was a fine seminary.

Father Dave Bechtel 06/12/09 05:54
Disgusted,

You make a good point, but since I don't speak for the bishop or work for the Diocese I cannot answer why they decided to handle this as they did. I can only try to explain why the decision is necessary, not why it was implimented the way it was.

Father Dave Bechtel 06/12/09 05:51
R,

Someone ALWAYS brings up that old worn out Ad Hominum about "Oh, you have too much time on your hands, blah, blah, blah..."

Let me tell you my day, shall I?

1) This morning I had to practice with a cantor for a special Mass in my Church which I am playing the organ for, for becasue a family asked me to play for their anniversary mass tommrow.

2) I then celebrated Mass at a Nursing Home.

3) I came back and "restocked" my supplies becasue it was then off to the prison for Mass, then individual time with people who wanted to see me.

4) When I came back from the prison I checked my mail, then went back to the nursing home to see a person I couldn't see this morning. Fortunately the home is right down the street.

5) In between all of this, I have been checking posts, etc. I admit this evening will be free, but most Friday's are unless I have a wedding or rehersal. Becasue of the nature of Friday's some parishes do not plan evening activities or meetings. Though some times I also have appointments on Friday's.

Want tommrow's schedule? I find it ironic that the people who also post on this site tell ME I have too much time on my hands, when the same could be said of them. I MAKE time to post here, becasue I see this as an important part of my ministry. Time is relative, and if you want time to do something, sometimes you have to MAKE it.

Father Dave Bechtel 06/12/09 05:47
"it is a shame that this is happening. By the time this Bishop is thru there will be no Catholic churches or schools left."

Yes, it is a shame that people want the church to adapt principles that are anti-Christian and anti-Biblical. Even if the RCC did change, I would bet even money that worthless sloths (AKA Catholics In Name Only) would still sleep in every Sunday, withold tithes and offerings, attend church only once or twice a year and complain about it as much as ever.

"People make their own decisions now and think and formulate what is right or wrong for their own life circumstances."

Right, it's all relative. What if what I think is right and you think is wrong suddenly clash? Who gets to decide who is correct? We can't use the Bible or historical Christian teachings according to you, so tell me, How do we decide? (And yes Pius, I really want an answer).

"Whether it survives in it's present form is uncertain. The Catholic Church closes churches, seminaries and schools. They close everything but the regal palaces, rectories and mansions where the hierarchy live. Anything the Catholic Church does now is based on money and for the survival of the institution and not for the God it was supposed to serve."

You and I live in the wrong neighborhood pal. Just look at the numbers of Catholics in other countries and how their numbers are growing in leaps and bounds (Philippines, Brazil,China) and check out their prognosis for the future. As I posted earlier, I can see the day when foreign preachers start evangelizing snotty, stuck-up quasi-atheists here in the West.

The real JC 06/12/09 05:39
Aquinas,

Priests already DO "adopt" kids and pay their tuition out of their own pocket. As for vacations, I have not gone ANYWHERE on vacation exept to visit my parents, and I will join them for a few days at the shore in August. I don't have the money for an extravagent vacation, but even if I did, I would not spend money on vacations becasue I am not a person that likes to travel. I would however like to visit the Southfork Ranch in Texas.

Actually if I had extra money to throw around, I would donate it to my parish music ministry program for better instruments. I would pay to have our pipe organ fixed.

In any case, why don't YOU adopt a kid or kids and pay their tution if the schools are so important to you? Why don't YOU give up YOUR vacations? If many people took your advice our schools would be overflowing. Why is this something the PRIESTS have to do, but not you?

Father Dave Bechtel 06/12/09 05:38
Father Dave, I think most reasonable would agree that closures might be nessary, but what I can't fathom is the cowardly way its done. Its one thing to ruin 55 family's lifes maybe for years, but to do to do it with a letter? And I understand this is happening all over to many many people, but the Church should be a beacon of humanity. Instead what we have is a coward running our church.
Disgusted 06/12/09 05:34
Half Off Nepa

1/2 OFF NEPA

Today's Feature: Steve Pronko Diamond and Fine Jewelry - Card Value: $50 Sale Price: $25. - Earning Your Trust Since 1928!

Home for the Holidays Contest

Answer the trivia questions for your chance to win 4 tickets to the NEPA Philharmonic's "Home for the Holidays" concert.

Win over Michigan State puts Penn State in mix BCS Bowl mix

Go figure: Penn State saved its best for last. Its passing game torched Michigan State's defense, making it look every bit like the 94th-ranked pass defense in the nation. Daryll Clark's four touchdown passes tied his career high. Even Curtis Drake, a tr


 

Win over Michigan State puts Penn State in mix BCS Bowl mix

Go figure: Penn State saved its best for last. Its passing game torched Michigan State's defense, making it look every bit like the 94th-ranked pass defense in the nation. Daryll Clark's four touchdown passes tied his career high. Even Curtis Drake, a tr


 

Goal-line stand keys Comets' District 2 title triumph

Push came to shove early in the District 2 Class AAA championship game, and Abington Heights was up to the challenge. Leading by a touchdown but with Dallas knocking at the door, the Comets got the defensive push they needed, shoving the Mountaineers bac